Many of my friends like this upload and I do too, even tho it was not a polished performance. Like somebody on YouTube pointed out, a lot of it is out of tune: the harp was damaged and out of tune, the guitars were not tuned to each other, and my singing, when I go "burnnnnn ...", is out of tune, I end up singing the same note as my siblings when I should be sustaining mine.
After many years of trying to sing the song on my own and struggling with it, I got the idea that it would be better for three voices to sing the DOWN DOWN DOWN and BURN BURN BURN parts where one voice comes after the other, followed by another. I am surprised that the Carter Sisters never recorded the song this way*. The three note melody line seems perfect for that kind of vocal arrangement. And when I think of the possibilities for this song, I like to imagine what Jazz vocal groups like the Andrews Sisters or Dining Sisters could have come up with for this song, had they recorded it.
We actually did a few takes after this, but I decided to stick with the first one, because the ones after were not much better anyway.
Ring of Fire sounds like it was written exactly for Johnny Cash to sing. But if you ever heard co-writer Merle Kilgore sing, he sounds a lot like Johnny Cash himself. The song was first recorded by Anita Carter, and in that record you don't hear the mariachi-style horn riff in Johnny's version. I can't imagine the song without that riff. It's part of the identity of the song. But having said that, British Rock group The Animals recorded a very nice Hard Rock version without that riff, and it works too, replacing it with a Western-style vocal chorus.
But my favourite version is the one by genius banjoist Earl Scruggs and actor-musician Billy Bob Thornton. Billy Bob's singing is fine, but Earl's picking really makes that riff come alive. Makes me feel like shuckin' corn man, whatever that means!
* Prior to writing this, I had never heard of this version by the Carter Sisters and Mama Maybelle. What can you say, it's just beautiful.
I know the song has quite recently become popular again, thanks to Adam Lambert of American Idol.
And I only added that last sentence with the hope of more hits for this blog. Sorry guys. :)
But my favourite version is the one by genius banjoist Earl Scruggs and actor-musician Billy Bob Thornton. Billy Bob's singing is fine, but Earl's picking really makes that riff come alive. Makes me feel like shuckin' corn man, whatever that means!
* Prior to writing this, I had never heard of this version by the Carter Sisters and Mama Maybelle. What can you say, it's just beautiful.
I know the song has quite recently become popular again, thanks to Adam Lambert of American Idol.
And I only added that last sentence with the hope of more hits for this blog. Sorry guys. :)
No comments:
Post a Comment